Well, Panthers, it’s a difficult job, but someone needs to do the work of tasting Crumbl cookies and reviewing them. We take our responsibility seriously as journalists to give the people the information they want to know. So, we tried this week’s Crumbl cookie lineup for you. Here are our thoughts:
Chocolate Chip Cookie
The cookie looks like a regular chocolate chip cookie but I loved how they topped it.The cookie has an airy, sweet taste to it and adding on the texture is crusty. Just to top it all off they add some flaky salt to top it. I give the cookie a 8.5 I think it’s a classic do I think I’ve had better chocolate chip cookies yes but this one is good and worth a try. I say people should get it. – Prisila
Cake Batter Cookie
Today I tried this week’s cake batter cookie from Crumbl Cookie. The cookie looked very presentable. It’s fluffy and has little pieces of sprinkles inside and outside and topped with a thick cream and crumbs. It taste delicious. It definitely has the cake batter flavor in it. It’s sweet and creamy. It’s chewy but has a bit of a crunch in it. If it was fresh and warm it would have been perfect. I truly recommend this cookie to those with a sweet tooth.Overall, I rate this cookie a 9 out of 10. – MaritzaThe cookie flavor I tried was Cake Batter and it was beautifully presented with white buttercream frosting and it had some sprinkles on top of it. The crust of the cookie was perfect and it had the same ‘milky’ flavor it usually always has, it tasted like a birthday cake and was overall really good. The cookie is a 10.5/10. I say 10.5 because the first bite tasted good as heck and so did the last, but overall I would absolutely recommend it to someone who’s never had Crumbl before, or someone looking to try new flavors. – Jaz
Today I tried this week’s cake batter cookie from Crumbl Cookie. The cookie looked very presentable. It’s fluffy and has little pieces of sprinkles inside and outside and topped with a thick cream and crumbs. It taste delicious. It definitely has the cake batter flavor in it. It’s sweet and creamy. It’s chewy but has a bit of a crunch in it. If it was fresh and warm it would have been perfect. I truly recommend this cookie to those with a sweet tooth. Overall, I rate this cookie a 9 out of 10. – Maritza
S’mores Cookie
The Crumbl s’mores cookie looks overall appetizing, chocolate drizzle with two marshmallows in the middle. That’s enough to captivate anyone right? Tasting the cookie was mainly pleasant, a tolerable sweetness. Although the marshmallow was very dry it was even stale. The cookie was definitely crumbly which didn’t disappoint on behalf of their franchise, but it was very dry and almost too dry. I feel as though maybe if this cookie was served warm, put it in your microwave and zap the dry little thing it wouldn’t hurt to give it some life. My personal star rating: 6/10, the s’mores Crumbl cookie is not worth the price, sorry not sorry. I would rather recommend buying a girls scout cookie, or your local super market cookie to get more for your money. It’s safe to say its not the best, not the worst, but it definitely has the potential to be even better. – Cienna
I got the S’mores crumble cookie It looks really good it has a chocolate drizzle and two marshmallows on it and the bottom of the cookie resembles a gram cracker. But it also looks dry and hard it definitely would only be good if it was warmed it looks like it’s been sitting for a while the marshmallow is hard. The cookie tasted really good but it would be better if it was warmed and the marshmallow was melted it tasted chocolaty and it was crunchy but the marshmallow paired well with the chocolate. Overall the cookie was good but only has potential If it’s fresh and warm i give it a 7/10 i would definitely say get this cookie but when it’s fresh and warmed. – Savanna
The cookie looks like a graham cracker base with chocolate drizzle and fluffy marshmallow. The cookie tasted chocolaty and wasn’t super sweet which I liked. The marshmallow paired nicely with the chocolate. However, this cookie would be better if it was served warm. I would give the cookie a 7/10. It wasn’t my favorite, but I did enjoy it. – Natalie
I got the s’mores Crumbl cookie. My cookie looks aesthetically pleasing, however the marshmallow is surprisingly hard. The chocolate drizzle was put on really cutely too. When I bit into the cookie, I noticed how hard the cookie was. I already have jaw issues and it hurts to just chew it. The cookie reminds me of a granola bar, and the chocolate is really sweet. The marshmallow doesn’t taste like a usual marshmallow, although I like how they included two on there. I’d give this cookie a 5/10 because it doesn’t taste bad, however the price point is not equivalent to the taste of the cookie. It’s around $5 for just one cookie, and I don’t think that’s fair, especially since it’s relatively small in size. If this cookie was warm, I’d probably raise my rating to a 6/10. However, it’s very inconvenient to heat up your cookie every time you want to eat it, which is why I didn’t raise my rating up that much. – Krisenda
Churro Toffee White Chip Cookie
The cookie I tried from Crumble Cookie was the Churro Toffee White Chip cookie, it had cinnamon and brown sugar around the cookie making it look like it had glitter with white chocolate chips inside. The cookie tasted like the cinnamon toast crunch cereal and the white chocolate is sweet. The cookie is very crunchy and crispy around the edges but the inside is a bit chewy. I will give the cookie 7 out of 10 because I have tried many cookies that taste the same like the Churro Toffee White Chip, so I will recommend people to skip it. – Evelyn
The cookie is round with a light brown and gold color to it with what looks like cinnamon sprinkled on top and has what seems to be a type of nut inside of it (what seems to be walnut). If you haven’t been living under a rock then you know what snicker doodle tastes like and this is what it tastes like. Just in case you have been living under a rock snicker doodle tastes like just a regular sugar cookie coated with a generous amount of cinnamon. honestly I give it a 9.5 /10 the only thing I feel should be added more is maybe at least another nut or two inside of the cookie. – Alex
Overall Thoughts
Overall, we give this week’s Crumbl lineup an 8/10. We say skip the S’mores one this week unless that’s your favorite flavor and you are going to eat it fresh and warm. This week, there were mostly yummy hits and just one or two misses.
What do you think we should review next? Comment below!
